Right or Righteousness?
Right or righteousness. That’s the title of the reflection today. I wonder what the difference is. Do I want to be right, or do I want to be righteous?
Righteousness is one of those words that has been co-opted dramatically by society in recent years. Let’s focus on a couple of definitions to begin with. In the Christian world being righteous means doing the will of God rather than your own. Your will or suggestions may co-incidentally be the same, but you were being driven by a requirement to let God take the lead.
Of course, in practical terms this means dumping your own self-serving requirements into touch, and following the need for the common good, for what would be right, what we think would be right in God’s eyes, and following that cause or course of action regardless of the negative consequences to ourselves.
Being right could be a whole other thing. A typical example might be, we know this is the way that something should be, and it’s the way we want it to be, and it may or may not be righteous, by the definition I just outlined earlier. But we’re going to go ahead and do it. Because we are right, and we know we are right. Or at least we’re convinced enough that we’re right, that we don’t want to leave any room for misinterpretation.
This can work out OK if we have enough authority that no one’s going to question whether we’re right or wrong to complete the task or do our will, sometimes necessary with children, slightly less effective in the adult world. But if we don’t have the right authority, and, God forbid we turn out to be wrong and that can start a whole different series of events to occur. Now we found out that even though we were sure we were right, and we told everyone we were right, and we instructed them to do what was right, by us, and then it turned out to be wrong.
Now what should we do? Admit we were wrong, cover it up, explain to others that they misinterpreted the instructions, or blame someone else. I think we’ve seen all these strategies in use around us in our lives at some point. Being 100% right, or rather being 100% sure that we’re right, can be a dangerous place to be. Certitude has been the predictor of many a downfall. Often our pride, and unwillingness to admit an error, lead us to lose credibility and trust amongst others, and our ability to learn from our mistakes.
I started this reflection by comparing right from righteous or righteousness. But there’s another little interloper in this process as well. Those who are self-righteous. Now while being self-righteous should be self-defining in some ways. It is about being right and righteous at the same time. Which may or may not be possible. I think for the most part people see someone as self-righteous, as someone who is defining their acts or words as coming from a higher source, with the added certitude of themselves thrown in for good measure. When someone accuses you of being self-righteous it’s usually not a compliment.
So where do we sit in the spectrum of right, righteousness and self-righteousness. We have probably all suffered at some point from all three points of this triangle. When we think about this in prayer terms, in our disposition towards God, a mindset or heartset on surrender is the only way that we can come to a righteous decision. And when we do can we proclaim it as being righteous? Without appearing to be self-righteous. Where do others in your life sit on this spectrum? As our sensitivity towards others increases, do we make the adjustments to accommodate their rightness, their righteousness, or their self-righteousness. Something to consider. Right or righteousness.

Both sides of the fence
Photograph and Reflection Copyright 2023 Michael J. Cunningham OFS

